← The simple act of voting

Indonesia · JakartaCity · Water

Giving water to the city without sinking it

Groundwater extraction can contribute to subsidence: reliable supply alternatives are needed to reduce it, in addition to limits on wells.

What the evidence tells us ↓
Indonesia · Jakarta. The neighborhood depends on intense groundwater withdrawals / A reliable network reduces reliance on wells
The neighborhood depends on intense groundwater withdrawalsA reliable network reduces reliance on wells
A mechanism, not a numerical forecast

How the change works

  1. 01 / Public decision

    Water supply and well rules

  2. 02 / Physical change

    Less dependence on the aquifer

  3. 03 / Possible outcome

    Subsidence to contain

Groundwater extraction can contribute to subsidence: reliable supply alternatives are needed to reduce it, in addition to limits on wells.

Research and local documents ↓
Documented case

What the evidence tells us

Research in Jakarta documents variable subsidence in space, linked to groundwater extraction, urban loads and subsoil conditions. The answer must combine water, planning and monitoring.

Qualitative comparison

Putting the choices into practice

Supply

The challengeDependence on wells

The responseReliable network

Soil

The challengeUnmeasured land subsidence

The responseMonitoring by neighborhood

Expectation

The challengeGround expected to rise again

The responseReduce further subsidence

The diagram compares choices and conditions for putting them into practice. Measured outcomes and their limits are discussed in the evidence.

Research and local documents ↓
Conditions and limits

Reducing withdrawals does not automatically raise the ground. The causes and speeds differ between neighborhoods; moving administrative functions does not heal Jakarta alone.

Other possible benefits

More reliable water services and better flood risk planning.

Research and local documents

  1. Local document and reported findingAbidin et al., 2015 · Land subsidence and urban development in Jakarta ↗

    Research on the case, mechanism, or measures discussed in the sheet.

Evidence reviewed:

Share a possibility.

Instagram and TikTok: save the image or use your device’s sharing menu.